Arendtsville Homes for Sale

Arendtsville Homes for Sale

Welcome to Arendtsville, Pennsylvania—a hidden gem nestled in the heart of Adams County. This charming small town is known for its picturesque landscapes, friendly community, and rich agricultural heritage. With rolling hills and breathtaking views, Arendtsville offers a peaceful retreat from the hustle and bustle of city life, making it an ideal place for families, retirees, and anyone seeking a tranquil lifestyle.

Arendtsville is steeped in history, with roots that date back to the 1800s. The town's quaint streets are lined with historic buildings and local shops, creating a warm, welcoming atmosphere. Residents enjoy a close-knit community where neighbors become friends, and local events foster a sense of belonging. The area is also known for its proximity to stunning natural attractions, including the Gettysburg National Military Park and the scenic trails of the Appalachian Mountains, perfect for outdoor enthusiasts.

For those looking to make Arendtsville their home, there are a variety of homes for sale that cater to diverse tastes and budgets. From charming historic houses to modern family homes, the real estate market here offers something for everyone. Whether you’re searching for a cozy cottage with character or a spacious home with room for growth, Arendtsville’s real estate options are sure to delight.

With its friendly atmosphere, rich history, and beautiful surroundings, Arendtsville is more than just a place to live—it's a place to call home. Discover your dream home in this enchanting town today!

Newest Arendtsville Homes for Sale

3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths

3 Bedroom, 1.5 Bath traditional farmhouse style home in Arendtsville. Large corner lot, shared driveway leads to a large detached 2 car garage. This home has lots of charm and needs a new owner to uncover it!

201 Main St, Arendtsville

Listing courtesy of Jeff A. Shaffer Real Estate, Inc.. Contact: 7174202981

Start Your Search

Jessica Sauls | Realtor | Memory Lane Property Group

With over two decades of experience and thousands of successful home sales, I provide calm, confident guidance through every stage of the real estate journey. Since 2003, I’ve helped buyers, sellers, investors, military families, and those navigating major life transitions make smart, well informed decisions. I do this with clarity, integrity, and strong advocacy. Real estate is more than a transaction, it’s deeply personal. I’m known for creating a steady, reassuring experience during what can often feel overwhelming. My clients value my ability to listen closely, communicate clearly, and protect their interests at every step. Whether negotiating complex terms, preparing a home for market, or navigating unexpected challenges, I lead with professionalism, transparency, and care. As a top performing Realtor in Maryland and Pennsylvania, I combine deep market expertise with a strategic, hands on approach. I help sellers maximize value through thoughtful preparation, including repairs and upgrades with payment deferred until closing. For buyers, I provide honest insight, strong negotiation, and a no-pressure approach. I want all of my Clients to move forward with confidence. Having successfully navigated multiple market cycles, I understand how to adapt strategies in changing conditions while keeping my clients’ goals front and center. Beyond real estate, I am deeply committed to my community, supporting scholarships, housing initiatives, and local education. That commitment to service carries into my work, showing up fully, advocating fiercely, and always doing what’s right for my Clients. If you’re looking for an experienced, steady professional who will treat your goals with care and deliver a strong, strategic outcome, I would be honored to work with you. It's my Mission to provide strategic, ethical, and compassionate real estate guidance that empowers people to build stability, wealth, and a life they love. We create calm, clear, and trustworthy experiences, and we strengthen our community through service, connection, and integrity. I believe in building futures, relationships, and legacies that last.

Learn More

Brian Sauls | Realtor | Memory Lane Property Group

Brian brings a thoughtful, detail-oriented approach to every real estate transaction. He helps clients understand the true condition and quality of a home beyond surface details, offering valuable insight during showings and throughout the decision-making process. Known for his calm demeanor, reliability, and strong attention to detail, Brian ensures clients feel comfortable, informed, and well supported from start to finish. He answers questions in real time, offers practical perspective, and helps buyers assess homes with confidence and clarity. Brian’s approach is grounded, professional, and service-oriented. His ability to provide meaningful guidance while keeping the process smooth and stress-free makes him a trusted advocate for his clients every step of the way.

Learn More

Christina Jones | Client Care | Memory Lane Property Group

Christina is the heart of our client experience and serves as our Director of Client Care. From the moment a client enters our world to well beyond the closing table, Christina ensures every detail is handled with care, clarity, and consistency. With a calm, organized, and compassionate approach, Christina manages communication, timelines, and behind-the-scenes coordination so our clients feel supported and informed at every step. She is often the friendly voice checking in, the steady hand keeping everything on track, and the person making sure nothing slips through the cracks. Christina is deeply committed to creating a smooth, low-stress experience for buyers and sellers alike. She understands that real estate transactions often come during significant life moments, and she brings patience, empathy, and professionalism to each interaction. Her focus on service, follow-through, and genuine care allows our team to deliver a thoughtful, high-level experience — one where clients feel heard, respected, and confident throughout the process.

Learn More

Payson Clausen Realtor

Payson Clausen | Realtor | Memory Lane Property Group

Payson Clausen brings together years of experience in real estate, media production, and marketing to support our team and elevate the client experience. With a strong background in both the real estate industry and creative media, Payson plays a key role in how properties, brands, and stories are presented. His expertise in video production, marketing strategy, and digital content helps ensure our listings and messaging are clear, compelling, and thoughtfully executed. Beyond his professional skill set, Payson is deeply committed to serving his community. He regularly volunteers his time working with local students and is actively involved in raising funds for SkillsUSA, supporting career and technical education programs that prepare young people for future success. Payson’s blend of industry knowledge, creative talent, and community involvement reflects our team’s values — using our work not just to serve clients, but to make a meaningful impact beyond the transaction. (function() { var rg = document.createElement('script'); rg.type = 'text/javascript'; rg.async = true; rg.src = 'https://widgets.realgeeks.com/static/js/search_widget_new.js?v=3'; var s = document.getElementsByTagName('script')[0]; s.parentNode.insertBefore(rg, s); })();

Learn More